A journalist, a sorcerer, a murder to solve. The magic system could use more magic, but the charm is real.
Synopsis

Sparks fly in this Gilded Age novel of mystery, magic, and romance by the author of the New York Times-bestselling Beasts of Prey.
Vesper Evans has always resented Basalton’s high society, and the sorcery that provides them with a luxurious life unimaginable to most. Orphaned as a child and rescued by the editor of The Basalton Globe, Vesper is now an ambitious reporter determined to keep her newspaper afloat.
While covering a lavish society gala, Vesper happens upon a shockingscene: the murdered body of a man she had spoken with just minutes before. Several of the powerful magical elite may want the man dead, but the primesuspect is wealthy industrialist Maximilian Kite.
Max soon makes Vesper a tempting offer: Find the culprit and restore his reputation in exchange for a substantial fee. Despite her distaste for Max’s world, Vesper agrees—the money would save the Globe, and the story would be the scoop of a lifetime. There’s only one catch: In order for her to infiltrate society, the two must pose as a courting couple.
Their investigation takes them from the highest echelons of privilege to the seediest backstreets of Basalton. As they unearth the city’s secrets and scandals, Vesper finds herself in grave danger—while falling for one of the most infuriating, arrogant, handsome men she has ever met .
Review
3.5 stars, and thank you PanMacMillan Export for my very shiny advanced reading copy!
I flew through this book. That’s worth saying upfront, because it means something.
Hawk & Sparrow follows Vesper, a young journalist with no money and a lot of nerve, and Maximilian, the heir to a long line of wealthy sorcerers, who could very well be accused of murder. He needs someone to help clear his name. He needs someone to help clear his name. She needs the money to save her newspaper from closing. They make an unlikely team, and Ayana Gray makes it work with a great deal of charm.
The world Gray builds sits somewhere between an industrial revolution and a fantasy novel, with magic reserved for a privileged few, and all the class tensions you’d expect from that kind of setup. Women’s rights are limited, the working class is exploited, and wealth protects the people it shouldn’t. It’s not a subtle backdrop, but it’s an effective one, and it gives the story stakes beyond the central mystery.
Vesper and Max are genuinely likeable, which matters more than it sounds. Vesper is sharp, resourceful, and big-hearted in a way that never tips into naivety. Max is charming and more empathetic than his upbringing has any right to have made him. I rooted for both of them, and I rooted for them together. The opposites-attract dynamic is as old as the genre, but Gray handles it with enough freshness that I didn’t mind.
The mystery itself kept me turning pages, even when I’d already guessed where it was going. And that’s my main frustration: some of the plot twists were visible from some distance, and watching the characters miss them for longer than felt reasonable tested my patience a little. I also wished the magic system had been developed further. It’s intriguing enough to make me want more, which is both a compliment and a mild complaint.
I did have to set aside one nagging question: why would Maximilian, with all his resources, hire a young journalist he’d just met rather than, say, a private investigator? The story never quite answers that convincingly. If you can make peace with it, and I largely did, the rest carries you through.
This is YA, clearly and unapologetically. The writing is fresh, occasionally candid in a way that suits the characters, and there’s no attempt to be darker or more complex than the story needs to be. Sometimes that’s exactly what you want.
Thanks for reading.
Sophie








Beautiful cover! Sounds like a good enough read, quick reads are good too! Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Great review!
https://lisalovesliterature.bookblog.io/2026/06/06/e-galley-review-the-music-of-us-by-emerald-alexandrea/
Despite guessing early on, this sounds good.
Yes it was!
Those characters just aren’t as smart as you.
Bwahahaha that must be it Sam! :-)
This sounds pretty good, but I suspect I would have issues with it too. That cover though, wow!
I know the cover is so lush!